School Bus Advertising Bill Crashes

Earlier this week I was disappointed to hear that HB199, “Advertisements on School Buses”, had died in the Utah House. HB199 would have allowed cash-strapped school districts to sell advertising space on the sides of Utah’s ubiquitous yellow school buses. Opponents to the bill cited concerns about safety and the possibility of inappropriate ads — despite the fact that bill allows districts to adopt guidelines for advertising and specifically outlines that advertisements shall be age appropriate; not contain a promotion of any substance that is illegal for minors (such as alcohol, tobacco, drugs or gambling); not promote any political party, candidate, or issue; and not promote sexual material. The bill failed by a vote of 44 to 27.

Despite the fact that education receives 100% of Utah state income taxes and a major chunk of all property taxes, our schools are hungry for revenue. Allowing schools to sell advertising on buses would have given schools access to new funding without raising taxes, which is precisely the type of innovative budgeting ideas for which Utahns are clamoring. According to the Daily Herald, putting ads on buses would have allowed schools to raise an estimated $3.3 million.

For years I have said that schools should follow the lead of the lucrative sports industry and take advantage of private-sector advertising dollars. If college football (Go Cougars!) can have, for example, the ‘Zion’s Bank Play of the Day’ or the ‘Verizon Wireless Dynamite Defender’, why shouldn’t public schools make money by christening a ‘Macey’s Library’ or a ‘Jamba Juice Media Center’? UTA currently reaps the benefits of selling advertising on public transportation buses, and no one is calling for its removal because it poses a danger to motorists or because it corrupts our children.

With our good conservative lawmakers taking a tough line on taxes, searching for innovative ways to bring in revenue and keeping a watchful eye over Utah’s students, I would have expected this bill to drive straight through the House and Senate and park safely on the Governor’s desk for a signature. I think the legislature missed the boat (or the bus) on this one.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in State Legislature. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to School Bus Advertising Bill Crashes

  1. nacilbupera says:

    Schools are currently facing impending cuts due to state cutbacks. If the question had been framed differently, I believe HB199 would have (and should have!) passed overwhelmingly.

    Here’s how it should have been framed: As a Utah citizen which of the three do you most closely support?
    (1) Cutting state funds to school districts
    (2) Raising taxes
    (3) Raising revenue through appropriate billboards on school buses (HB199)

    Since the House rejected the last and we are overtaxed as a state, there seems little choice but to cut budgets.

    An additionaly benefit of HB199 would be that of empowering or “freeing” the local school district to make revenue decisions. In the business world we would hail this as appropriate “deregulation.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s